Propane vs Electric Heat: What Actually Works Out Here
If your home sits on a few acres outside Silverton, or on a ranch somewhere in Briscoe County, the choice between propane and electric heat isn’t something you debate in the abstract. It comes down to what keeps the house warm when a blue norther rolls in, what you can count on when the temperature drops 40 degrees overnight, and what still works when the grid doesn’t.
We’ve been delivering propane to homes and farms across the Texas Panhandle since 1972. We’re not here to sell you something you don’t need. This is a straight look at what the two systems actually offer — and where each one makes more sense.
First: Why Natural Gas Usually Isn’t an Option
Most conversations about home heating compare propane, electric, and natural gas. Out here, that third option often isn’t on the table.
Natural gas distribution follows population. Pipelines run where the density of customers makes the infrastructure investment worth it. Silverton had 629 residents at the 2020 census. Much of Briscoe County is farmland and ranchland with homes scattered miles apart. Running natural gas service to individual properties in this part of the Panhandle simply doesn’t happen the way it does in Lubbock or Amarillo.
So the real comparison — for most rural households in this area — is propane versus electric. That’s what we’ll focus on.
How Propane Heating Works
A propane furnace works the same way a natural gas furnace does. Fuel flows from a tank on your property through a line into the furnace, where it burns to produce heat. The system distributes that heat through your ductwork. Your tank gets refilled periodically by your propane supplier — us, in this case.
Because the fuel is stored on your land, you control your supply. You’re not drawing from a shared utility grid. If you want four months of fuel in the tank going into fall, you can have it. That independence is one of the main reasons propane has been the default for rural homes in the Panhandle for generations.
Propane also runs more than just a furnace. Water heaters, ranges, clothes dryers, outdoor grills, and standby generators all run on propane. Many of the homes we serve use propane for several appliances, not just heat.
The Heat Energy Difference
One fact worth knowing: according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration, one gallon of propane contains 91,452 BTUs — British Thermal Units, the standard measure of heat energy. Propane is energy-dense. That’s why it can heat a space quickly and why a full tank goes a long way.
Electric resistance heating converts electricity directly into heat. It’s simple and effective, but electricity is measured in kilowatt-hours, and each kilowatt-hour contains about 3,412 BTUs. The relative cost-effectiveness of the two fuels shifts based on local electricity rates and current propane prices — both of which fluctuate.
Electric heat pumps work differently. Instead of generating heat, a heat pump moves heat from outside air into the house. In mild weather, this process is very efficient — it can deliver more heat energy than the electricity it consumes. In very cold weather, outside air has less heat to extract, and efficiency drops. For a Texas Panhandle winter that can swing from 65 degrees one afternoon to single digits the next morning, that variability is worth keeping in mind.
What Comes Out of the Vent
This is a difference you can feel with your hand.
A propane furnace delivers air at roughly 120 to 140 degrees at the vent. Step in front of a register and you feel genuine warmth. The room heats fast.
A standard electric heat pump typically delivers air around 95 degrees — below body temperature. The air is warmer than the room, so it will raise the temperature over time, but it doesn’t feel warm the way gas heat does. Some people describe it as cool air blowing from the registers, even when the thermostat is calling for heat. On a below-freezing night in Briscoe County, that difference matters.
What February 2021 Showed Us
You don’t need us to tell you about Winter Storm Uri. Most people in this part of Texas lived through it.
The numbers from FERC’s official post-event report: more than 4.5 million people in Texas lost power during the storm, some for up to four days. FERC called it the largest controlled firm load shed event in U.S. history.
Homes heated entirely by electricity had no heat. Homes with propane tanks that still had fuel in them kept their furnaces running.
That’s not a claim that propane is immune to supply problems — propane prices spiked sharply during that storm, and demand in some areas outpaced delivery capacity. But it does illustrate a simple reality: if your heat depends entirely on the electric grid, a grid failure takes your heat with it. If your heat runs on fuel stored on your property, a grid failure doesn’t automatically mean a cold house.
For a household 30 miles from the nearest shelter, that distinction carries real weight.
Equipment Life
Propane furnaces typically last 15 to 20 years. Electric heat pumps typically last 10 to 15, because the same unit runs year-round for both heating and cooling instead of sitting idle through the summer. Both vary with maintenance and brand, but the gap is consistent.
Over 30 years of homeownership, a propane furnace may need to be replaced once. A heat pump may need to be replaced twice. Factor in the installation cost of each replacement and the difference adds up. This isn’t the only number that matters, but it belongs in the calculation.
Where Electric Heat Has Real Advantages
We’ll be straight about this.
Modern electric heat pumps — particularly cold-climate models — are genuinely efficient in mild to moderately cold weather. They provide both heating and cooling in a single system, which simplifies your HVAC setup and eliminates the need for a separate air conditioner. They don’t require a propane tank on your property. In some cases the installation cost is lower than a full propane setup with a new tank.
If you’re in a newer home close to town with reliable grid service and mild winters, a heat pump is a reasonable choice. If your existing electric system works well and hasn’t given you trouble, there’s no compelling reason to switch just to have propane.
The question is what fits your situation — your home’s location, your comfort priorities, and how much the grid reliability question weighs on you.
What We See in Briscoe County
Most of the homes we’ve served over the decades use propane as their primary heat source, often with a backup electric space heater or window unit for shoulder-season use. That combination gives them the reliable warmth of gas heat along with some flexibility.
For anyone building on agricultural land outside of town — in Briscoe, Motley, Hall, or Swisher County — propane is almost always the more practical starting point. The fuel is available, the equipment is proven, and you’re not betting everything on infrastructure that doesn’t reach your property.
If you’re weighing a system change, or just want to understand your options, call us. We’ve been in this community long enough to give you a straight answer.
Learn about our propane delivery service, request a delivery estimate, or contact us directly at (806) 823-2451. We serve Silverton, Quitaque, Turkey, Tulia, and the surrounding Panhandle communities.
